Good overall experience with my first car rental.

Excellent service, they provided a free upgrade.

Problems with the vehicle : terrible smell when turning the fan on (we had no choice to turn it on as it was raining...), The gas was not full as it was supposed to be because they had too many reservations on that day (it is really hard to gage how much you put to get the same level as when you got the car). And it was dirty inside... Not the best experience with the car. Besides that, very nice staff.

The vehicle was a little old and smelled of smoke.

Like: The value for the car was great - saved close to $90 from what the competitors offered!
Dislike: I rented a car in the middle of winter in Canada, and I was given a Dodge Challenger muscle car. I actually asked for a Toyota Yaris or similar. Look --great car, but it had summer slicks on, not even all-weather tires. Further, I was told by the agent when I got back that the treads were getting pretty low. Sure enough, I was caught in a snow storm, and I got stuck and I had to be towed out. So, poor choice of car. Even poorer choice that the car did not have winter tires.